Metal Shingle Roof Cost: A Pro’s Perspective

My partners and I have been installing and repairing shingle roofing, both metal and traditional asphalt, for years. When home and building owners ask about metal shingle roof costs, they want to know: Is it worth it? Having been there for countless roof installs, from asphalt shingles to premium metal systems, we are going to walk you through the real numbers — and how having a manufacturer/distributor that sells direct can help you get not only some of the best values in metal roofing, but help you learn and become educated about the metal shingle roof product.

📊 What Does a Metal Shingle Roof Cost?

Here’s what you will likely see across the board:
Material costs typically range from $3 to $7.50 per sq ft for steel shingles, and $4 to $16 per sq ft for aluminum, zinc, or copper

Installed cost averages around $6 to $14 per sq ft, often totaling $9,000 to $35,000 on roofs between 1,500–2,500 sq ft (see Why Install Costs Vary)

Breakdowns show material + installation often equal $6–12.50 for steel, $7–12 for aluminum, with copper/zinc higher.

One guide pegs average installed cost at $6–23 per sq ft, with the national average closer to $10–16
newenglandmetalroof.com

💡 Installed vs. Asphalt Roofing
To compare, asphalt shingle roofs generally cost $4.50–12.25 per sq ft ($6,000–$9,800 total)
thisoldhouse.com

Yes, metal roofs cost more up front—but consider this:

Durability: Metal shingles can last 40–70 years, in contrast to asphalt’s typical 15–30 years

Energy savings: Metal reflects heat better—potentially lowering cooling costs by up to 40%
thisoldhouse.com

Return on investment: A durable metal roof might save you from paying for a replacement 2–3 times during the life of an asphalt roof.

🧮 Why Install Costs Vary

As someone who’s been in the field for years, I can tell you these are the key cost drivers:
Roof complexity: Features like slopes, valleys, dormers, and chimneys add labor and cost
theroofdoctors.net

Existing roof removal: Tear-off adds $1–5 per sq ft, depending on layers and disposal fees

Material type and gauge: Heavy-gauge steel, stone-coated shingles, or copper cost more than standard steel
forbes.com

Region/labor rates: Installation labor varies by location and regional contractor rates .

Warranty and finish: Premium coatings like Kynar 500® raise material costs, but improve long-term performance.

🌪️ How Metal Shingles Hold Up in High Winds

One of the most underrated benefits of metal roofing is its superior wind resistance. As someone who’s witnessed the storm repairs and reroofs after major wind events, I can tell you: metal shingle roofs outperform asphalt in most severe weather conditions.
Many of the metal shingle systems offered through Best Buy Metals — even the more affordable profiles — have passed Florida Building Code standards, including:

✅ Florida Product Approval (for statewide hurricane zones)

✅ Miami-Dade County Approval (among the strictest wind uplift standards in the U.S.)

These certifications mean that the roofing system can handle wind speeds up to 160+ mph, depending on the system and installation details.

⚖️ How Does That Compare to Asphalt Shingles?

Let’s be fair: some premium asphalt shingles are rated for high wind, and certain brands meet the 110–130 mph range. However:
Standard 3-tab asphalt shingles often carry only 60–70 mph wind ratings

• Asphalt is more prone to lift, curl, or tear during storms, especially as it ages
• After a hurricane or severe storm, it’s common to see shingle roofs needing patchwork or full replacement
• By contrast, metal shingles interlock on all sides and are mechanically fastened to the roof deck, giving them a much better chance to stay intact during high winds.
• In areas prone to hurricanes, tornadoes, or derechos — or if you just want peace of mind — a metal shingle roof can be a smart investment in storm protection.

🔧 Why I Recommend Best Buy Metals and trust Best Buy Metals:

They’re a manufacturer & distributor with nationwide reach via BestBuyMetals.com and local/regional branches at BestBuyMetalRoofing.com

Over 20+ years in business means reliable, factory-direct pricing, fast delivery, and quality assurance.

Their product lines include top metal shingle options:

Sentry Shingle — lifetime limited warranty, PVDF Kynar 500 finish, 4‑way interlocking

Cottage Shingle — 26‑gauge stone-coated steel with hurricane protection

Granite Ridge — low-profile stone-coated steel that mimics traditional shingles.

Because they are a manufacture, they give contractors a lot of leeway to pass savings directly to homeowners—and I feel confident in product quality and availability.

💰 Final Take: Is Metal Shingle Roofing Worth It?

Here’s what I will tell homeowners:
Upfront, expect $6–14 per sq ft installed, depending on materials and roof complexity.

While this is 50–200% more than asphalt, proper metal roof installs will last twice as long or more (40-70 years) and could very likely be the last roof you have to install.

You’ll save on future replacements, energy bills, and possibly insurance—plus add curb appeal and resale value.

With Best Buy Metals, you can get factory-direct pricing, regional support, and a team backed by 20+ years of experience.

If you’d like a customized estimate for your house—based on size, style, and material choice—reach out through BestBuyMetals.com or your local Best Buy Metals branch. They will be happy to guide you through options and costs.